$80 billion could help IRS increase audits of the wealthy, which have dropped in last decade
Wednesday, April 28, 2021
President Joe Biden's proposal to give the Internal Revenue Service an extra $80 billion over the next decade to go after tax cheats — which the ol' blog talked about earlier this month in this post — is getting a lot of attention in advance of his nationally televised speech night.
I suspect the current IRS hierarchy is pleased, despite the comments to The New York Times by a former commissioner that an extra $25 billion over a decade would be sufficient.
"I'm not sure you'd be able to efficiently use that much money. That's a lot of money," said John Koskinen, whose term as IRS Commissioner ended Nov. 12, 2017, of Biden's 10-year, $80 billion proposal.
The debate over the exact amount of money in fiscal year 2022 for the IRS and how it should be apportioned will continue, both in the media, among the tax community and, most importantly, on Capitol Hill.
There is, however, more consensus that the IRS needs to keep a closer eye on the wealthiest filers.
More tax attention to rich needed: Current IRS Commissioner Charles Rettig told a House Ways and Means subcommittee in March that one of the reasons the agency stuck with the April 15 estimated tax deadline was because:
"There's a large contingent of wealthy individuals in this country who do not make their estimated payments and who essentially take the money they should be paying in quarterly estimated payments to the government and take the arbitrage, invest it, and we're not going to give them a break of interest and penalties to do so."
At a follow-up hearing before the Senate Finance Committee in April, Rettig elaborated on the IRS' focus on rich taxpayers.
"Over the past two years, we have shifted significant examination resources and technology to increase our focus on high-income and high-wealth taxpayers," noted Rettig in his prepared testimony.
But that attention hasn't paid off, at least not yet.
Despite Rettig's touting of extra attention to the returns filed by the rich, he also acknowledged that IRS examinations, which is the official agency term for audits, of those returns have decreased. His testimony continued:
"As reported in the IRS's most recently published Data Book (2019), the exam coverage rate (closed and in-process) for Tax Year 2015 of taxpayers with income of $10 million or more was about 8.16 percent (down from almost 23.06 percent in 2010). The rate for taxpayers with income between $5-10 million was 4.39 percent; for those with income between $1-5 million was about 2.39 percent; for those with income between $500,000- $1 million was about 1.13 percent; and for those with income between $200,000-$500,000 was about 0.55 percent."
More data, fewer audits of the wealthy: Independent reviews of IRS audits confirm this trend.
IRS audits of high-income taxpayers continue to decline, according to a recent report by the Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse (TRAC) at Syracuse University. Only 2 percent of millionaires were audited in 2020,
Specifically, TRAC found that the IRS audited only 11,331 of the 637,212 returns filed by people reporting more than $1 million in income in fiscal 2020.
That's a 72 percent decrease from fiscal 2012, says TRAC, when the IRS audited 40,965 millionaires.
Now audits are dropping even though the number of millionaires in the United States has almost doubled less than a decade, says TRAC.
Rich have richer tax resources: Budget and staffing cuts get the primary blame for the reduced examination rates.
"The decline in revenue agents undermines the agency's work because revenue agents are the only auditors qualified to examine complex tax returns, and complex tax returns are precisely the types of returns filed by high income individuals and large business firms," says TRAC.
Rettig's April testimony underscored the need for properly trained agents to review these filings.
"Substantially all experienced examiners – those who are the most highly trained with substantial accounting skills – are almost entirely focused on tax returns that include complex issues, such as high-income taxpayers, pass-through entities, multi-national taxpayers involving international tax issues, large pension plans, private foundations and the most egregious situations," the commissioner told Senators.
The rich, they are different: That IRS specialized training and expertise is needed because, as F. Scott Fitzgerald famously said, "Let me tell you about the very rich. They are different from you and me. They can afford the best tax attorneys."
OK, the great American novelist didn't say that part about high-dollar tax advisors (or, as I glibly tweeted earlier, avoid audits), but he could have.
And that's why Biden is proposing such a big boost to the IRS budget in this area.
With all due respect to former commish Koskinen, without the funds to adequately train and utilize more examiners, the IRS likely will continue to, as TRAC argues, let billions of dollars in tax revenue due from the country's wealthiest taxpayers slip through its fingers.
You also might find these items of interest:
- IRS says it did a pretty good job in a COVID-affected year
- IRS commissioner says Tax Gap likely $1 trillion, thanks largely to cryptocurrency
- 7 former IRS commissioners chastise Congress for slashing the tax agency's budget, urge full funding
You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.