How does your state and local tax deduction compare?
A tax break gift for educators on National Teacher Day

Trump's continued weekend travel, NYC home security costs raise more tax questions

The president is back in Washington, D.C., after spending the weekend not at Mar-a-Lago in South Florida, but at a closer family property, Trump National Golf Club in Bedminster, New Jersey.

A view of the golf course at Trump Bedminster via at-Trump_Trump Organization via Twitter
A view of the Trump National Golf Club course at Bedminster, New Jersey. (Photo courtesy Trump International via Twitter)

It was the 14th weekend since his inauguration that Donald J. Trump has headed to one of his eponymous real estate holdings.

Trump explained his weekend travel decision twice on, of course, Twitter.

First, on May 5, he Tweeted: "Rather than causing a big disruption in N.Y.C., I will be working out of my home in Bedminster, N.J. this weekend. Also saves country money!"

Then the next day, he added: "The reason I am staying in Bedminster, N.J., a beautiful community, is that staying in NYC is much more expensive and disruptive. Meetings!"

Trump's travel (and more) costs: His acknowledgement of the expense seems to indicate that Trump is at least aware of the complaints about how much his penchant for being at one of his pre-election homes is costing the U.S. Treasury, not to mention that all that money is going back into Trump accounts.

The cost of just Trump's air travel for two weekends in Florida, according to a recent Wall Street Journal examination, was $1.3 million.

A new website, Is Trump at Bedminster?, is keeping track of not only the prez's whereabouts, but also the costs of his weekend departures from the national capital.

Trump at Bedminster 050617 Instagram via Twitter

Then there's the added cost of the First Lady and Trump's youngest son still living in their Trump Tower home in Manhattan. Those expenditures were the focus of a New York Times  reader's recent letter to the newspaper's editor:

Re "Budget Deal Allots $120 Million More for First Family’s Security" (news article, May 2): President Trump has told us he is a billionaire. He has also, as a public service, offered to serve as president for $1. It seems only natural, then, that the president, in a similar spirit of civic-mindedness, should insist on paying these security costs himself. Besides, the cost might be tax-deductible.

Anything that mentions tax automatically catches my attention. This is an intriguing suggestion — not that Trump cover his family's added security costs himself, but that he might get a tax break if he does so — so I took it to some experts, specifically a group of Enrolled Agents who share their tax guruness on Facebook.

Enrolled Agents weigh in on tax implications: Responses ranged from very succinct one-word replies to more detail considerations of the tax possibilities if Trump ponied up personally for some of his and his family's added costs to maintain their pre-public service lifestyles.

Thanks to all the Enrolled Agents who took time to ponder this matter and offer their advice.

Below are some of the comments that particularly caught my attention. The comments have been lightly edited, mainly to clear up some tax-speak that tax pros tend to use with each other. Also, the links in the comments go to Don't Mess With Taxes  posts (or my stories) on the issues mentioned by the tax pros.

  • I think that would be a very tenuous deduction and I would not take it. First, Melania is not the POTUS, Donald is, so Melania's upkeep costs are Donald's not the taxpayers. Second, a house is provided to Donald that meets the "convenience of the employer" test, and that house is in DC, not NYC. Third, Donald's tax home is DC, not NYC and the engagement is anticipated to last longer than a year, so the Temporary Assignment rules do not apply. — Steve Katz 

    I agree with all of Steve Katz's points. Fails on all measures at the outset and even if it didn't, his deductions would be limited by the Pease itemized deduction limit threshold and then hit with the dreaded Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT). — Kathy Morgan   

    Say he did list it, and the IRS did audit it, all Steve's comments would apply. Also, if spouse does not work with the organization, her/his expenses are not deductible (spouse's attendance at annual convention as an example). Maybe he needs to appoint her to an empty slot on his cabinet. — Judy Mereness Strauss 
  • Under his employer reimbursement policy, he is entitled to having the government pay for his family's security. Therefore, if he pays it out of his own pocket, it is not deductible. — Shirley Garner Johnson 

    Bingo! — Lisa Skidmore Sexton
  • The tax savings on paying his own expenses would dwarf the value of the services provided as essentially a "tax free stipend"(although even as POTUS wouldn't the value of any goods/services he receives beyond what's regularly provided in travel allowance and Secret Service protection for family members still be taxable?) With that in mind, if you were in his shoes would you take the tax benefit theoretically worth up to 39.6% (not considering AMT, 2% limit on miscellaneous deductions and any other limits on these deductions) OR the "tax free stipend" worth a full 100%? — Clint Masser

Tax questions beget more tax questions: As you can see, Trump's unconventional presidency has yet again raised tax questions.

The consensus in this case is that, for many reasons, Trump wouldn't get any tax benefit for picking up the tab for any of his added travel and family security costs.

But the original tax question also underscores what all of us in the tax world have long known. Tax questions often lead to as many additional questions as answers.

Maybe that tax tendency will be reduced by any tax reform accomplished by the Trump Administration. But I wouldn't count on it.

Sponsored Links

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Himani Sharma

That’s a great post . It will definitely help me. I would love you to read this:

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)